Health & Personal Care > Health Care > OTC Medications & Treatments > Pain Relievers > Non-Aspirin > Acetaminophen

1. Tylenol PM Extra Strength Pain Reliever + Sleep Aid

Ranked 1st in our list of recommended acetaminophen and sells for $25.90 (as of 08/07/2023 07:29 PDT details ) , more than 89% of the Tylenol product reviews are positive. With features such as with acetaminophen for fast acting pain relief and temporarily relieves occasional headaches and minor aches and pains with accompanying sleeplessness, it is indeed our top pick among acetaminophen.


2. Goody's Extra Strength Headache Powder

In the 2nd place of our top acetaminophen list you'll find the Goody's TRTAZI11A which garners positive reviews from more than 100% of customers who bought acetaminophen. Priced at $28.93 (as of 05/12/2018 16:04 PST details ) , it is designed for the savvy consumer who don’t mind paying a bit more for quality and best in class features.


3. Goody's Pain Relief Powder Pm

Number 3 on the best acetaminophen list is resereved for venerable Goody's product that has featuers like, pack of six, 16 count total of 96 count and for fast pain relief with sleeplessness. With a positive sentiment of 94% for the product from Goody's, it is a solid purchase that will keep you happy and it can be found online for $31.19 (as of 07/08/2018 03:48 PDT details ) .


4. Tylenol Arthritis Pain

At $27.01 (as of 05/12/2018 16:04 PST details ) , Tylenol's 575589 is our number 4, which gets 95% approval rate from customers who actually bought it.


5. Tylenol Extra Strength Value Pack 200 tablets Easy to Swallow 500mg each

A good, solid choice come up at number 5 of acetaminophen reviewed by us. You can find this Tylenol Vaue pack - 200 Tablets Easy to Swallow for $28.00 (as of 23/08/2017 11:22 PDT details ) , and be sure that it will do the work, at least according to more than 100% of people who used it and enjoyed features such as tylenol extra strength value pack and value pack.


6. Percogesic Extra Strength 40 Caplets

If none of the acetaminophen listed above suits you, then perhaps the Percogesic PPAX1153240 at the 6th place is the right one for you. Costing $31.56 (as of 05/12/2018 16:04 PST details ) , positive reviews hover around 100%.


7. TYLENOL 8 HR Arthritis Pain Extended Release 650 mg Caplets 225 ea

Last but not least in the top acetaminophen, we have the good old Tylenol PPAX1144080 which gets great marks by 100% of the reviews posted. It can be bought for $57.88 (as of 05/12/2018 16:05 PST details ) .



Click here to browse more Acetaminophen products